Skip to main content

About Automatic Memory Management

In general, there are two methods through which automatic memory management can be achieved in programming languages: garbage collection (GC) and smart pointers.

Smart pointers are special data structures that keep track of the reference count of a dynamically allocated object. In languages like C++, these structures typically use the RAII (Resource Acquisition Is Initialization) principle to manage dynamically allocated references. Smart pointers can be shared, counting references and shareable by multiple owners, or unique, where only one owner can hold a reference at a given time.

An alternative to smart pointers is garbage collection. At runtime, a program routine called the garbage collector tracks references, and as long as references are accessible from a reference on the stack, the memory for those references will not be recycled. Otherwise, objects will be destroyed, and memory deallocated. Languages with garbage collection are quite popular, such as C#, Java, and Go.

Both solutions have advantages and disadvantages:

AdvantagesDisadvantages
Smart pointersDeterministic program runtimesCan be misused depending on specialization
Better runtime performance in terms of time/memory consumedLearning their usage can be more complex depending on use case
Easier to implement than GCProblems can still arise if used alongside raw pointers
Garbage collectionProgrammers don't need to explicitly manage GC presenceProgram runtimes are non-deterministic
Easier to prevent memory leaksMaking memory leaks is harder but not impossible, especially with forgotten threads
More challenging to implement compared to smart pointers